| 1850 | Samuel K. Hutchinson |
| 1851 | Samuel K. Hutchinson |
| 1852 | Nathaniel W. Quint |
| 1853 | Nathaniel W. Quint |
| 1854 | Nathaniel W. Quint |
| 1855 | William B. C. Pearsons |
| 1856 | William B. C. Pearsons |
| 1857 | William B. C. Pearsons |
| 1858 | Arbee C. Slater |
| 1859 | Arbee C. Slater |
| 1860 | E.B. Wheeler |
| 1861 | Thomas C. Page |
| 1862 | William B. C. Pearsons |
| 1863 | Thomas C. Page |
| 1864 | B.S. Bucklin |
| 1865 | B.S. Bucklin |
| 1866 | Henry Wheeler |
| 1867 | Quartus Lovering |
| 1868 | William Grover |
| 1869 | William Grover |
| 1870 | Marden W. Prentiss |
| 1871 | Marden W. Prentiss |
| 1872 | Alvin C. Pratt |
| 1873 | Alvin C. Pratt |
| 1874 | Charles H. Prentiss |
| 1875 | Charles H. Prentiss |
| 1876 | Henry J. Sawtelle |
| 1877 | Henry J. Sawtelle |
| 1878 | William Orrell |
| 1879 | William Orrell |
| 1880 | William Orrell |
| 1881 | Lewis M. Richards |
| 1882 | Lewis M. Richards |
| 1883 | Charles C. Hunter |
| 1884 | Charles C. Hunter |
| 1885 | Charles C. Hunter |
| 1886 | John E. Bronson |
| 1887 | John E. Bronson |
| 1888 | John E. Bronson |
| 1889 | John E. Bronson |
| 1890 | John E. Bronson |
| 1891 | Cyrus B. Wolcott |
| 1892 | Cyrus B. Wolcott |
| 1893 | Jarvis U. Woods |
| 1894 | Jarvis U. Woods |
| 1895 | Eli W. Beech |
| 1896 | Eli W. Beech |
| 1897 | Frederick N. Ricker |
| 1898 | Dennie L. Farr |
| 1899 | James Auld |
| 1900 | James Auld |
| 1901 | John J. Morton |
| 1902 | Archibald A. Brooks |
| 1903 | Archibald A. Brooks |
| 1904 | Wilbur H. Stedman |
| 1905 | Wilbur H. Stedman |
| 1906 | William H. Morehouse |
| 1907 | Abraham Davis |
| 1908 | Abraham Davis |
| 1909 | Albert E. Webster |
| 1910 | Louis Strauss |
| 1911 | Edward T. Newton |
| 1912 | Charles E. Alderman |
| 1913 | Oliver W. Adams |
| 1914 | Robert Gillette |
| 1915 | Daniel W. Williamson |
| 1916 | Raymond W. Gero |
| 1917 | Herbert G. Rose |
| 1918 | Andrew Purves |
| 1919 | George Barnett |
| 1920 | Robert W. Hunter |
| 1921 | David Coutts |
| 1922 | Harry L. Simard |
| 1923 | David M. Thomson |
| 1924 | George H. Sinclair |
| 1925 | Stuart D. Coward |
| 1926 | William Graham |
| 1927 | Alexander D. Pratt |
| 1928 | Edgar L. Renner |
| 1929 | Harrington B. Fay |
| 1930 | John Partington |
| 1931 | James G. Sinclair |
| 1932 | Allen S. Hunter |
| 1933 | Robert M. Hunter |
| 1934 | Joseph A. Waugh |
| 1935 | William F. Putnam |
| 1936 | John F. Foster |
| 1937 | William B. Hogg |
| 1938 | Ernest A. Stache |
| 1939 | Claude W.R. Thomson |
| 1940 | F. Ray Green |
| 1941 | James B. Tiffany |
| 1942 | Charles M. Gillette |
| 1943 | Walter Uhlman |
| 1944 | Joseph A. Wood |
| 1945 | Robert B. Clapp |
| 1946 | Emory V. Easteling |
| 1947 | Arnod L. Smernoff |
| 1948 | James R. Smith |
| 1949 | James W.M. Bryden |
| 1950 | Robert H. Aitken |