| P | |
| 2Palmer, Monroe | 1850 |
| 2Pearsons, William B. C. | 1850 |
| 2Preston, James H. | 1853 |
| 2Page, T. C. | 1856 |
| 1Pierce, E. G. | 1857 |
| Prescott, Morrill | 1860 |
| Parsons, Charles W. | 1860 |
| Pinkham, L. | 1862 |
| Persons, Albert C. | 1863 |
| Persons, Edgar S. | 1863 |
| Persons, Horace J. | 1863 |
| 1Pratt, Alvin C. | 1864 |
| 1Prescott, J. T. | 1864 |
| Prentiss, Marden W. | 1865 |
| Prentiss, George W. | 1865 |
| 2Philbrick, H. B. | 1865 |
| Peterson, John | 1865 |
| 1Pomeroy, Edgar J. | 1866 |
| Prentiss, Robert T. | 1867 |
| 1Post, John S. | 1868 |
| 1Perkins, William S. | 1869 |
| 1Prentiss, Charles Herbert | 1869 |
| 1Perkins, Levi | 1869 |
| 1Percy, Calvin D. | 1869 |
| Patterson, William | 1870 |
| 1Page, Thomas C., 2nd | 1870 |
| Pease, George | 1870 |
| 1Perkins, Edwin | 1871 |
| Pratt, John A. | 1873 |
| 1Paul, Albert A. | 1873 |
| Pease, Edwin L. | 1873 |
| 2Parker, Aldorado D. | 1874 |
| 3Proctor, James | 1874 |
| Perkins, George | 1875 |
| Prentiss, William A. | 1876 |
| 3Page, Albert H. | 1879 |
| 2Pease, Louis A. | 1881 |
| 3Porterfield, David H. | 1881 |
| 2Perkins, Edson A | 1883 |
| Preston, Charles H. | 1883 |
| Preston, Joseph S., Jr. | 1884 |
| 2Perkins, Justin B. | 1885 |
| Phillips, James | 1887 |
| Polley, Sidney S. | 1889 |
| Porter, Clarence M. | 1890 |
| Phillips, Francis D. | 1895 |
| Purves, Andrew | 1895 |
| Perry, Albert H. | 1895 |
| Parfitt, James, Jr. | 1899 |
| 2Pomeroy, Frederick W. | 1899 |
| Phelps, Frank J. | 1900 |
| Pihl, Carl M. | 1900 |
| Pennell, Alvin H. | 1900 |
| Perry, Walter E. | 1901 |
| 1Paul, Alexander W. | 1902 |
| Pierce, Edwin H. | 1903 |
| 2Prentiss, Samuel L. | 1903 |
| 2Prentiss, Ralph N. | 1903 |
| Palmer, Ralph B. | 1904 |
| Pease, Arthur F. | 1906 |
| Pringle, William A. | 1906 |
| Peck, Theodore A. | 1906 |
| Potts, George | 1908 |
| Prowler, Jacob F. | 1908 |
| Putnam, Harry. | 1909 |
| Prentice, George M., Jr. | 1909 |